13099 S Cleveland Ave Ste 310, Fort Myers FL ● 8855 Immokalee Rd #4, Naples FL
13099 S Cleveland Ave Ste 310, Fort Myers FL
8855 Immokalee Rd #4, Naples FL

I want an insurance quote for...

life-insurance-icon@2x
Life
auto-insurance-icon@2x
Auto
homeowners-ins-icon@2x
Home
motorcycle-ins-icon@2x
Motorcycle
boat-insurance-icon@2x
Boat
umbrella-ins-icon@2x
Umbrella
renters-insurance-icon@2x
Renters
flood-insurance-icon@2x
Flood

“We are not your typical insurance agencyOur philosophy is simple:
Treat people like we would want to be treated.”

Brian Culbertson

Agency Principal

I want an insurance quote for...

life-insurance-icon@2x
Life
auto-insurance-icon@2x
Auto
homeowners-ins-icon@2x
Home
motorcycle-ins-icon@2x
Motorcycle
boat-insurance-icon@2x
Boat
umbrella-ins-icon@2x
Umbrella
renters-insurance-icon@2x
Renters
flood-insurance-icon@2x
Flood

“We are not your typical INSURANCE AGENCY.
Our philosophy is simple:
Treat people like we would want to be treated.”

—Brian Culbertson, Agency Principal

The Culbertson Agency is a leading personal lines insurance company with offices in Fort Myers and Naples. We are dedicated to treating others how we’d like to be treated. Over 90% of our customers renew their policies with our agency year over year. That says a lot about who we are.

 

Get to Know Us…

Brian Culbertson

Corporate Office

Kristen Cantoni

Naples Office

Matt Pendleton

Fort Myers Office

Amy Mandala

Fort Myers Office

Ruth Villanueva

Fort Myers Office

Johnny Barrett

Fort Myers Office

Marcello Casanova

Fort Myers Office

Billy Cornell

Naples Office

Coy Nuzum

Naples Office

Daniel Barbosa

Fort Myers Office

Dhimir Patel

Fort Myers Office

Jada Morse

Fort Myers Office

Jeffrey Bonany

Fort Myers Office

Jordan Nickelson

Fort Myers Office

Jose Rodriguez

Naples Office

KC McReynolds

Naples Office

Michael Beeson

Fort Myers Office

Nichole Ellis

Fort Myers Office

Tyler Small

Corporate Office

Nicole Gray

Naples Office

Rebecca Rundle

Fort Myers Office

Insurance We Offer

What kind of insurance are you interested in?
Umbrella Insurance
Auto Insurance
Flood Insurance
Motorcycle
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
ATV, Golf Carts & Toys

Featured Articles

Our Naples Insurance Agent was Featured in Five Star Professional and Gulfshore Life

One of the things that the Culbertson Agency prides itself in is that we consistently make the top lists in our industry. Recently, one of our Naples insurance agents, David Cantoni, was featured in Five Star Professionals portion of the Gulfshore Magazine. We've included a screen grab of his section: Gulfshore Magazine has been featuring the very best of ...
read more

Fort Myers Family Staycation Itinerary for Under $2,500

The Culbertson Agency likes to give back to our surrounding community and one of the ways that we like to do that is by helping you explore the possibilities for recreation and relaxation that’s available to us right here in our own backyard. Since most people don’t vacation as single adults, this guide is assuming that you have a spouse or significant ...
read more

3 Affordable Outdoor Home Security Cameras

When it comes to home security, you can’t ever be too prepared. Many homeowners are turning to the power of outdoor surveillance systems to ensure their possessions are safe while they are away, and that their family is protected while home. Some smart home systems can even grant homeowners additional discounts on their insurance premiums. We’re here to ...
read more

What Our Clients Are Saying


I filled the form out online to get a quote for homeowners insurance. Within the hour I received a quote from Jordan. This quote ultimately save us 1285.00 off of 2017 rate and 2,300.00 off of our current 2018 rate. Thank you Jordan and Culbertson Agency. You made the whole process just short of effortless!!!

Sonya

Request a Quote