“We are not your typical insurance agency.
Our philosophy is simple:
Treat people like we would want to be treated.”


Brian Culbertson

Agency Principal

The Culbertson Agency is a leading personal lines insurance company with offices in Fort Myers and Naples. We are dedicated to treating others how we’d like to be treated. Over 90% of our customers renew their policies with our agency year over year. That says a lot about who we are.

Get to Know Us…


Culbertson Agency Brian Culbertson Corporate

Corporate Office

Culbertson Agency Kristen Cantoni Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency David Cantoni Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Matt Pendleton Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Amy Mandala Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Ruth Villanueva Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Johnny Barrett Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Matt Brown Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Marcello Casanova Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Amy West Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Billy Cornell Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Coy Nuzum Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Daniel Barbosa Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Dhimir Patel Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Jada Morse Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency KC McReynolds Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Lismary Alvarez Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Rebecca Rundle Fort Myers

Fort Myers Office

Culbertson Agency Savanna Baker Naples

Naples Office

Culbertson Agency Tyler Small Corporate

Corporate Office

Insurance We Offer


What kind of insurance are you interested in?

Featured Articles


City of Palms Classic 2017

The Culbertson Agency of Fort Myers is a sponsor for the City of Palms Classic basketball tournament happening at the Florida SouthWestern State College's Suncoast Credit Union arena from December 18th to the 23rd.

2017's Top 10 Dangerous Toys

This is one of those things that crops up every year around Christmas because it's the time of year when toy-buying is highest. I can remember being a kid playing on the living room floor with a jump rope and I remember wrapping it around my neck to play like I was wearing it as a kind of necklace when my mom suddenly urged me to take it off because I could strangle myself. This was in the eighties just before the time of the Cabbage Patch Kid doll that would eat little-girls' hair.

Why Millennials Can't Afford to Miss Out on Life Insurance

When respondents in the insurance survey were asked how much a $250,000 term life policy for a healthy 30-year-old would cost each year, the median estimate was $500, over three times the actual cost of $160. Millennials in the study, ages 18 to 36, guessed an even higher amount: 44% pegged the cost at $1,000 or more a year, compared with 29% of older respondents, the insurance study said.